Primacy All Season TIRE REVIEW
There are 268 reviews for the Primacy All Season
Rating Snapshot
When asked, 40% of reviewers recommend this tire
Review Summary
Reviewers are sharply divided, with most reporting premature tread wear and dangerous failures—tires reaching unsafe levels at 8,000 to 25,000 miles despite warranty promises, with blowouts and sidewall ruptures at highway speeds raising serious safety concerns. Many customers express betrayal, stating Michelin's reputation has declined and vowing not to repurchase. However, some praise the quiet, smooth, comfortable ride quality, particularly on OEM installations. Overall, durability issues and safety anxieties dominate customer sentiment, overshadowing positive driving experience feedback.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
1-10 on 268 reviews
So far so good! Always been a fan of Michelin tires. I have used the Defenders on my Out acts and Forester s with good results
Went over some gravel and tarmac and it dropped really low. The other tires are fine
Great EV Tires
Great tires. These came with my new Ford Mustang Mach-E back in 2022. It's been almost four years now. I have put over 75,000 miles on this, and still have some thread left
Smooth ride and great handling!
Great tire - Very poor wear.
2021 Ford Explorer ST came with these OEM. Ride, noise , braking and traction are great. Fuel efficiency is hard to compare without changing tires because all cars have different numbers. Problem is that only after 26,500 miles my dealer said I needed new tires. I am pushing the bald tires past 32k miles now. Hoping to get to at least 35k miles. Road conditions have been pavement. Drive less than 30 miles each day. Driving habits are not aggressive and half freeway and half residential. Tire inflation maintained and monitored by car computer. Probably going to replace soon with Toyo AT III as they were great on my Ford Ranger pickup.
Great tire except does not last
Tire came with car lasted less than 25,000 miles.
Solid tires
Came with these on my 2022 Equinox. I'm getting ready to trade the car but really loved these tires. I'm amazed at the bad reviews. Trading my car with 50.000 and still have original tires, with tread left and very little wear.
Self seal is amazing
These have been AMAZING tires. We got these when we ordered our 2022 ford explorer. It is 2026 & they have been so great. I got a bolt the size of my pinkie in my tire & it was a 1 inch bolt. I had to use pliers & twist the bolt out & there was no air loss. Ive also found a screw & a nail in them.
Absolute horrible tires. Do not buy!
Horrible durability. I drove only 150 days on gravel roads and all my truck tires have many large chunks taken out of the tread. I now have a leak. These are horrible tires. Tread is way too soft. I will not buy Michelin again.
We’re sorry to hear about your experience and understand how frustrating this must be. We recommend having your tires inspected by an authorized tire dealer, especially given the air loss you mentioned, to ensure your safety and determine the cause. Please give us a call and provide your inspection results at 866-866-6605 (Mon–Fri 8 AM–7 PM EST, Sat 9 AM–1 PM EST).
Michelin US
June 26, 2026
Michelin All-Season
This is an excellent tire. Great grip and smooth operation. Leads to improved full economy. Especially great in wet weather! Long tread-wear life!