Find Dealers

Primacy All Season TIRE REVIEW

There are 247 reviews for the Primacy All Season

Bibendum icon

Rating Snapshot

2.8/5
40 %
For any matter regarding customer service (in-store experience, after-sales service, delivery, etc.) please contact our Consumer Care team

Review Summary

The reviews present a mixed sentiment about the tires. Some customers report positive experiences with the tires, such as great handling, comfort, and traction. However, a significant number of customers have had negative experiences, including rapid and uneven tread wear, poor performance in adverse weather, frequent air leaks and punctures, and questionable durability. While some customers praised the quiet ride and overall performance, the negative reviews seem to outweigh the positive ones.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

131-140 on 247 reviews

Sort by

Review Details

  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • This is what happened at 7500 miles
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • 2different tires
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Grooved roads, which are now my biggest nightmare
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Foam failure
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
1 20
Posted on January 5, 2026 by patimco
1/5

Warning--Dangerous Tires

Horrible! at only 7500 miles on a new Mercedes Benz GLC 300 4-Matic the left rear tire blew out while traveling 80 mph on Interstate 95 in southern Georgia, and could have cost my husband his life as he negotiated crossing three lanes of traffic to reach the berm. The response from Michelin? A case number, no help, no follow-up. A Michelin rep said take it to a MB dealer, the dealer said it was a waste of time and Michelin wouldn't do anything. Long story short--we replaced the tire with out own money. The car did not hit or run over anything to puncture the tire. It just completely separated from the rim. Air pressure was good, as the car monitors it. These were OEM tires that Mercedes uses for that model. We are terribly angry at the situation and Michelin. The only thing I received from them was a case number--no phone call or follow-up. So disappointing from a company that I once considered a better brand. No more Michelins for us!

Vehicle Make: Mercedes-Benz GLC300 4-Matic
Purchase date: 07/31/25

Pamela, we’re very sorry to hear about the incident you experienced with your Primacy All Season tires. A member of our Consumer Care team will follow up regarding your case soon. You can also reach us at 866-866-6605 (Mon–Fri 8 AM–7 PM EST, Sat 9 AM–1 PM EST).

Michelin US

January 12, 2026

Posted on September 6, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
3/5

Bad tires

I bought this almost 2 years ago and I need to change because it’s yellow and I need to replace with only 20,000 miles

Design
3
Safety
3
Performance
3
Purchase date: 09/30/22

Bob 27, please have the tires inspected by your local Michelin retailer (preferably the selling dealer), and contact us at 866-866-6605 8am-5pm EST Mon-Fri upon inspection so that we can get more information.

September 10, 2024

Posted on August 13, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
5/5
I recommend this tire

Micheln OEM tire was perfect, replaced at 40000, same tire

I replaced OEM tire with same Primacy Loved the tire Quiet, good ride and handling, good tread life

Design
5
Safety
5
Performance
5
Purchase date: 08/13/24
Posted on August 9, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
5/5
I recommend this tire

very good ratings

Look good

Purchase date: 07/25/24
Posted on July 31, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
5/5
I recommend this tire

Great tire.

Came on my 22 Corolla se nightshade. 73,000 miles and now just replacing. I don’t know what the complaints are about. Nice handling, sticks in corners. Great wet road tire. I’m very pleased with this tire. Just can’t afford to purchase for replacement. They are pricey but if I had the money I would definitely purchase this tire. I did have them rotated regularly.

Design
5
Safety
5
Performance
5
Purchase date: 06/01/22
Posted on July 28, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
5/5
I recommend this tire

great

great

Purchase date: 07/05/24
Posted on July 21, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
1/5

Terrible design

These tires came installed on my new Hyundai Ioniq 5. Last week I experienced vibrations and shaking in my steering wheel going down the freeway. After Hyundai service department inspected the tire they informed me that the reason for the shaking was due to the “noise reducing “ foam built into the wall of the tire that had come detached. They indicated that they had seen some of these issues and told me that if I had driven over pot holes this happens. I was offered a replacement tire (same tire). In my view this is a major design defect if a tire is so sensitive that you can't drive on normal streets that could have pot holes which aren't always avoidable without the foam coming off the wall and causing the steering wheel to vibrate and become out of balance.. I'm not happy about having to replace a tire for this issue after having had it for only 1 year. Especially knowing that it is something I can expect to encounter again in the future. I don’t drive off road, I drive on normal streets with normal hazards. I do not recommend these tires and am looking to replace all tires with a sturdy durable tire that do not have this design defect.

Design
4
Safety
1
Performance
1
Purchase date: 06/19/23

CVP, we're sorry to read of this problem. We'd like to help. Please take your vehicle to an authorized Michelin retailer for an inspection of the tires. Call us at 866-866-6605 8am-5pm EST from the dealer so that we can see how to assist.

July 30, 2024

Posted on July 19, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
3/5

Still noisy after replacement

Pretty good tires but wont be installing them again still getting road noise.

Design
4
Safety
4
Performance
3
Purchase date: 07/19/24

Troy719, Our records show that you have been in contact with our Consumer Care team and a solution has been reached. Give us a call at 866-866-6605 8am-5pm EST should you need further assistance.

July 30, 2024

Posted on July 12, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
2/5

Mediocre

These tires came from the factory on my new ford. They are completely worn out before hitting 30,000 miles. Pretty disappointing performance.

Design
3
Safety
3
Performance
2
Purchase date: 10/24/22

Kyles, sorry to read that your tires are in need of replacing prior to delivering the expected mileage. We'd suggest taking the vehicle to a local Michelin retailer for an inspection of the tires. Contact our team at 866-866-6605 8am-5pm EST Mon-Fri while you are at the dealer location so that we can get additional information and see how to proceed from here.

July 29, 2024

Posted on July 8, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
1/5

Concerned about sidewall thickness

These tires were on the new Chevy Equinox EV and I developed a slow leak in the sidewall I don't know if it was my fault or not but if you saw it you go that must be the tire

Design
3
Safety
3
Performance
3
Purchase date: 06/13/24
The leak

Billy Bob, I see that you have been in contact with our Consumer Care team. Should you need further assistance, give us a call at 866-866-6605 8am-5pm EST Mon-Fri.

July 23, 2024

Posted on July 3, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
5/5
I recommend this tire

Great gas mileage

Tires came with car, best gas mileage and 74.000 treadwear, changed before wear indicator. I changed tires to Primacy tour A/S And getting about five miles per gallon less than Primacy A/S Road noise is better

Design
5
Safety
5
Performance
5
Purchase date: 03/11/20
1...131415...25